Process map · Manufacturing

Returns and credit notes in a manufacturing company

When a manufacturer's goods come back, the credit note is the small part. The real questions are which production run made them, what else that run produced, and whether the cause was the process or the raw material. This map follows a complaint from the customer back through the batch to the work order and, where the trail leads there, to the supplier.

Select a step to see who does it, the document and the ERPNext screen.

Step by step

  1. The customer reports a defect and wants to return the goods. The salesperson logs it with the batch number printed on the label, the quantity affected and photos, and passes it to quality at once.

    Who does it
    Salesperson
    Document that comes out
    Issue

    ERPNext then does this by itself

    • Emails to and from the customer are kept on the record
    • The request stays open until someone closes it

    Without an ERP

    The complaint is handled by sales as a commercial problem. The customer gets a credit, the factory hears nothing, and the same defect ships again next month.

  2. The storekeeper opens the original Delivery Note and makes a return from it, with the quantity that actually came back. It is a delivery note with the quantities reversed, usually into a separate returns warehouse.

    Who does it
    Storekeeper
    Document that comes out
    Delivery Note (return)

    ERPNext then does this by itself

    • Stock goes up at the cost it went out at
    • More cannot be returned than was delivered
    • The original delivery shows how much has come back

    Without an ERP

    Returned cartons are left near the loading bay. They are not on the stock sheet, so they are neither sold nor credited, and at the year-end count nobody knows whose they are.

  3. The inspector confirms the defect on the returned goods, then follows the batch number back. It leads to the stock entry that made the batch, and from there to the work order and the batches of raw material that went into it.

    Who does it
    Quality inspector

    ERPNext then does this by itself

    • The batch record points to the entry that produced it
    • Other deliveries of the same batch are listed in the stock ledger

    Without an ERP

    Nobody can say which run made the faulty goods. Either a whole month's production is sorted by hand to be safe, or nothing is checked and the next complaint is awaited.

    ERPNext 16: Submitted manufacture stock entry against a work order: four raw materials consumed from work in progress and 30 finished boards received
    ERPNext 16 · Stock Entry (Manufacture)
  4. Accounts make the credit note from the original Sales Invoice, for the quantity the store received back. Items, prices and VAT come from that invoice, so the customer is credited exactly what they were charged.

    Who does it
    Accountant
    Document that comes out
    Sales Invoice (credit note)

    ERPNext then does this by itself

    • Sales, VAT and what the customer owes are reduced
    • The credit note names the original invoice and carries the TRN
    • The credit shows on the customer's statement at once

    Without an ERP

    Credit notes are typed in a word processor from memory. The price is today's, not the one charged, the VAT is wrong, and the store never confirmed the goods came back.

  5. If the original invoice is still unpaid, the credit note is matched against it in the Payment Reconciliation tool and the customer simply owes less. If it was paid, accounts refund the money with a Payment Entry, or leave the credit on the account and match it to the next invoice.

    Who does it
    Accountant
    Document that comes out
    Payment Entry

    ERPNext then does this by itself

    • The customer's balance and credit room update at once
    • Credits not yet used are listed until they are matched or refunded

    Without an ERP

    A credit is promised but never applied. The customer short-pays the next invoice by their own figure, and the two sets of books never agree again.

    ERPNext 16: Payment Reconciliation tool for Coral Heights Developments listing outstanding sales invoices beside two unallocated payments
    ERPNext 16 · Payment Reconciliation

The Full map adds 10 more steps: the approvals, checks and branches between these.

For example
A customer returns 200 cartons because the print rubs off. The batch number points to one work order and one drum of ink. The cartons are scrapped, the rest of the ink goes back to its supplier, and a non-conformance records what will change.

What changes in a manufacturing company. The same process, the steps this industry really uses.

  • The batch number is the thread

    Finished goods carry a batch number from the day they were made. It ties the customer's complaint to the work order, the date and the batches of raw material used.

  • A return opens a quality record

    The fault is logged as a non-conformance with its corrective and preventive action, so the same defect does not come back with the next order.

  • Rework comes before scrap

    Goods that can be put right go back to the shop floor on a work order, and the extra materials and hours are recorded against it.

  • Faulty raw material goes back to its supplier

    When the trail ends at a bad batch of raw material, what is left of that batch is returned and a debit note raised, with the inspection readings as evidence.

Where this map leads

Processes feed each other. Follow the work into the next map.

Free tool

Build your company's map

Pick your industry and the processes you run. Get one printable document with every map and step, ready to show your team or your ERP partner.

See it live in a demo
  • Returns and credit notes
  • Order to cash
  • Purchase to pay
  • Plan to produce
  • Hire to retire

Questions about returns and credit notes

Ask us anything else
Can ERPNext trace a customer complaint back to a production batch?
Yes, when finished goods are made with batch numbers. The batch on the delivery note leads to the stock entry and the work order that produced it, and that entry lists the batches of raw material used. The stock ledger shows which other customers received the same batch.
How do we record the cost of rework and scrap?
Rework can be run as a work order, so the materials and time it uses are recorded like any other job. Scrap is written off with a stock entry to its own account, so the profit and loss report shows what poor quality cost in the period.
Can we return faulty raw material after some of it has been used?
Yes. The return is made from the original purchase receipt for the quantity still in stock, and the debit note covers that quantity. A claim for the goods already made with the faulty material is agreed with the supplier separately.

See this process run on your own data

A 45-minute ERPNext demo that follows this map with an example from your business.